Friday, January 26, 2007

Ysabel

My speculative fiction book group has read a collection of fables and the Odyssey in order to talk about myths and legends as a sort of proto-speculative fiction, a forerunner of modern SF, or even the SF of its time. It's an interesting discussion to have, because as we surpass a century of "modern" SF, some of the earliest stories have a feel to them similar the ancient myths and legends. The speculative parts of the stories no longer hold up to any sort of examination and they remain as an artifact of the period they came from.

I don't know if Guy Gavriel Kay is any sort of mythographer, but the foundation on which his novels is built is the idea that myths and legends are manifestations of universal tropes--the important elements of individual myths are universal. It's very Campbellian, but Kay the novelist finds this to be fertile ground in which to work his art. And what he does, better than any writer I know, is take the awe-inspiring power of the mythological and legendary, and wrap up the thoroughly mundane in it. In most myths, any average person who gets in the way of the gods is usually made to regret their ill luck. But Kay tries to tell the legendary through the eyes of the generally powerless and point out how they are integral and key to the events of the myth and legend. Ordinary people touched by myth are not doomed in Kay's writing; they are, however, changed (usually physically and emotionally). This does not mean that Kay dumbs down his legends to where they are vapid--fortunately, Kay spends time working honestly through the complexities of the legends, and does it through the eyes of the mundane, so that the reader can see both the majesty of larger-than-life figures and their very humanity at the same time.

Kay's latest novel, Ysabel, is yet another example of the brilliance he employs in his craft. Ned Marriner, 15, is in Provence while his world-famous photographer father is working on an art book about the region. During a break, Ned meets a young girl named Kate in a cathedral in Aix, and she acts as an informal tour guide for him. Together they run into a strange, scarred man, who seems abnormally strong and, they eventually realize, some hundreds if not thousands of years old. Through their interaction with him, Ned and Kate find themselves drawn into the latest manifestation of a chain of events that has repeated itself for thousands of years. Because of the sheer lifetimes of the creatures involved and the magic that surrounds both their longevity and the circumstances that ensnare them, Ned and Kate find themselves trapped in a legend, whose horrible end they know and recognize may be their own ends as well.

But Kay does something different with Ysabel. At last, the novel takes place on the Earth think we know. And the magic which has such interesting properties in his other novels set in other places, is both weaker and more supernatural than the magic of the standard high fantasy. Instead, the force that moves the characters through the novel is equal parts fate and sheer human stubbornness. Ned and the characters that surround him are determined not to let the end they see coming actually arrive, though when they ask themselves what they think they might be able to do, they never know. Only when decision is required of Ned does he somehow know the right thing to do, because he has become part of the legend, the narrative that binds them all together. The two supernatural protagonists that Ned most often interacts with ask him repeatedly "Who are you?" and while he does not have an answer that suits him or them, he most often says "I'm in the story."

Kay is not a wonderful stylist; his words don't leap off the page. However, his skill does seem to lie in story-telling, creating a compelling narrative and populating it with three-dimensional characters. The pacing of his stories is immaculate--not a wasted word or effort--and the reader is simultaneously impatient to find out what happens next and breathless from the speed of the events in the narrative. In Ysabel, there is no real sense that any of the characters are evil, but they do have their dark sides. But this is not to say they are all boring either. They are individuals, wrapped up in events bigger than themselves and trying to win free. And because of Kay's art of building up the action and then setting it free, that we both want to linger with these people we like and also hurry them into whatever the narrative holds for them.

I admit it; I am a huge fan of Kay. I was elated to receive an early copy of this book, one I had been looking forward to since I turned the last page of his previous novel. I am predisposed to like what Kay writes, but I honestly believe in the power and art of his craft. I don't ever want to put down one of his books, and that surely reflects on his ability to tell a story.

Sunday, January 21, 2007

Pan's Labyrinth

This is somewhat the second of a themed pair.

One of the more popular story-telling devices in current use is to take the threads of seemingly unrelated plots and tell them interchangeably, until the relationship between the threads is made clear. The movie Crash is a good example of this type of structure; in speculative fiction, Iain Banks and Steven Erikson have mastered it in their works. Guillermo del Toro's most recent movie, Pan's Labyrinth, purports to do the same kind of thing. One plot thread deals with the last days of the Spanish Revolution, as we follow the story of Ofelia going to meet her step-father, a captain in the Spanish National Army trying to quash a cell of revolutionaries in the hills. The second story also involves Ofelia, as she discovers that she is the long lost princess of a fantasy underworld kingdom; to return to her rightful place, she must complete three supernatural tasks.

While Ofelia is the common element that binds these two threads together in the movie's tapestry, something is missing from the structure that is being attempted. In the first place, Ofelia is not an important part of the Spanish Revolution thread; most of the events that take place do not involve her and she knows nothing about them. In the second, there needs to be something more than a character to tie the threads up in any sort of satisfying way; there should be some sort of unity in thematics or meaning, a commonality that is wholly missing from Pan's Labyrinth.

The revolution thread is a fairly standard war story; no new ground is covered by the movie. In fact, the events of the revolution plot are entirely, and sadly, predictable. Of course there is a traitor in the captain's camp, and of course, as soon as that traitor is uncovered, the rebels start their last big push. The images are as graphic as the best war pictures being made today, and I'm not altogether sure that's a good thing in this case. If this was just a movie about the war, it would be critically roasted as derivative and no one would care to see the movie.

Sadly, the fantasy thread is terribly sparse, not really fleshed out with the possibilities inherent in a fairly standard fantasy trope. Neither are the scenes in that plot very exceptional either, actually perhaps somewhat less interesting than the best efforts in the fantasy genre recently. Doug Jones is fairly impressive as the faun, and none can doubt his acting ability as his real persona is hidden by tremendous prosthetics. But the fantasy here is the fantasy of the original Grimm stories; it is brutal and vicious and not particularly tidy. I could deal with unappetizing fare, if I knew it was going to lead to something greater than the parts, but this fantastic brutality is fetched up beside the war scenes, and it just makes for what quickly becomes an unrelentingly brutal picture.

And so I am left wondering if I missed something. Critics around the world are hailing Pan's Labyrinth as the work of genius, but at its end, I only find two unrelated plots, mediocre on their own, and downright frustrating as they are interwoven. What was gained from the intertwining of these two narratives, especially since each offers very little as reflections or sounding boards for the other thread. Even more unconscionable, to me at least, is the movie's suggestion that the fantastic elements are not true at all, but the imaginings of a scared young girl. But this reading of the movie falls apart, because Ofelia has nothing to fear for most of the movie, and the fantastic tasks she performs have effects in the real world that persist after she has completed them. What is gained then by hinting half-heartedly that the narrative for half the movie is broken? And what have all the critics who have celebrated this movie seen that I cannot see? Why is this considered good cinema when it certainly was nowhere near as good as Children of Men, which in turn has gotten very little press at all.

One of my movie companions, who admittedly has strict taste, expected a far different movie from the one we saw, given the high praise heaped upon the movie. She is convinced that no one has the strength of their conviction to tell the emperor he is wearing no clothes. Her husband, whose opinion (like his wife's) I lean upon when making decisions about what movies to see, felt that the movie is another entry into the field of "war is hell." My own opinion lies somewhere between these, and I circle back to my thoughts for the first ten minutes after I walked out--what did I miss? What connection ties the two threads together to lift this movie beyond merely experimental and flawed film-making? There is no cinematographical genius on display with this movie; neither is the acting much above mundane. I'd like to give the film-maker credit for trying something new, but what was attempted by the combining of these two stories is beyond me. And so this movie has become, in my mind, a film example of the phenomenon of Bradbury's novels. People who are paid to tell me what is good have exalted these subjects of their review, and I just can't see it. And I wonder how many people are disappointed by the books or the movie, but have convinced themselves that they should like it just because "smarter" people, professional reviewers, have told them that they should.

So, until someone can explain to me why this is a great movie, I'd recommend staying away from it. And if it takes someone to explain it, I'm not sure I can recommend it once it all gets sorted out.

Something Wicked This Way Comes

This will likely be the first of two posts today. Coincidentally they will be on a theme. This first regards a book I've read for a book group, so I won't be going into much detail here.

I consider myself a pretty big fan of Ray Bradbury; I've read a good number of his short stories and thoroughly enjoyed them. I've been to conventions where he has appeared and been swept up in the good feelings for him from the standing ovations that follow him like a shadow. One of my basic assumptions about the literary world is that he is one of the greats, and it will be a sad day when he passes.

The book group I participate in read Fahrenheit 451 a few years ago. It has the reputation of validating Bradbury's career; everyone knows about it (though very few people have ever read it) and it has had culture-changing impact. But while I find the plot to be mesmerizing and poignant, I found the writing itself to be pretty bad, bordering on immature as the experiments Bradbury attempts with the style just seem to keep missing the mark. But it was actually the first novel by Bradbury I had read, and his greatness must be based on the breadth and depth of his work more than any one novel.

The same book group has selected Somthing Wicked This Way Comes, and I find myself with the same problem. The story seems straightforward enough, or as straightforward as any sort of supernatural suspense story can be, but I found myself getting completely lost in the gyrations the language and style of the novel takes. Poetic language can be wielded beautifully, and I imagine it should be used delicately as well, but the effect from Something Wicked is more like a poetic sledgehammer wielded by someone learning the nuance of sledgehammering. When the style and language of a work detract me from the meaning and intent of the work, something is dreadfully wrong. It could be argued that some works may in fact be exercises in style, and that Something Wicked is famous exactly for its stylistics. However, I don't think I've read any reviews of Bradbury's work that praise its style.

So, I'm left with a meditation on reputation. And of course, this leads one to ponder questions of taste. As a caveat, let me repeat that I think Bradbury has earned his implicit title pf master writer for hos work in the short story form alone. But as a result of these two books, I don't intend to ever read another novel by Bradbury unless I am bribed with at least the cost of the book plus recompense for my time if I don't like it. But I wonder how many people actually really like Bradbury's novels or, if in fact, few people who praise Bradbury have actually read his novels. I wonder if his literary popularity is such that anything he writes is immediately branded a classic; hundreds of critics have said it in the past, so it must be true now, right?

I've also never read The Da Vinci Code, which makes me a sort of social outcast at dinner parties. I'm reminded of the Saturday Night Live sketch with the commercial for a Broadway production featuring a hypnotist; the commercial consists of a buoyant announcer backed up by real audience reaction, except that each audience member interviewed repeats the exact same praise in a dead monotone, "It's better than Cats. I'll see it again and again." Clearly The Da Vinci Code touched some integral part of some of its readers--Christian conspiracy or perhaps the need to believe in something being bigger than the world we know, even if it is hidden. But the critics hated it, and the people I know whose opinions I trust have told me not to bother reading the book, as it is very poorly written and not very compelling besides. And I have felt the ostracism that results if you dare to challenge the book's greatness. But when I ask a fan of the book why it's so great, there is nothing concrete in response. And you know, "Everyone's reading it" is not a real good reason for me to want to read it.

In fact, it was fashionably revolutionary for while to admit to not reading The Da Vinci Code. I was like the beatniks in the 50s, daring to question authority in by black clothes and beret. But I find it isn't so terribly cool to say that perhaps Bradbury has some warts, especially when I am attempting to don the costume of serious speculative fiction critic. I suppose it is no help that Bradbury is also an incredibly personable and friendly man. And of course, I could just be out on the fringe of the mainstream (which is where I usually am when talking about the value of speculative fiction). Maybe we should question things that have been co-opted by the mainstream. Was Bradbury ground-breaking? He may well have been, for 50s mainstream readers. But how does that fit into the experience of the reader of speculative fiction in the 50s? Perhaps he was treading ground that other, less popular writers had been to before. And maybe , as a reader of speculative fiction, I should appreciate his success as a sort of liaison between us and the mainstream reader; lord knows he is one of the few SF writers that non-fans can name when challenged.

I suppose that this means I should eventually read some Vonnegut as well. As if my reading list wasn't long enough already.